Remember the old Jimmy Stewart movie, “It's a Wonderful Life”?
It's Christmastime in early 1940s small town America. Stewart
plays a banker at a savings and loan who has loaned money to the
poor to help them build decent homes. Now he faces ruin at the
hands of a heartless Lionel Barrymore, who has found a misplaced
bank deposit, called in the auditors and started a run on
Stewart's bank. But the "little people" who Stewart put his
faith in prove him right. They stream in with their dimes and
quarters and dollars to bail him out.
Fast-forward half a century. A computer has replaced Jimmy
Stewart. Whether you get a loan to buy a home CAN depend on a
computer-generated credit score that compares certain things
about you. Things like how much money you earn, how long you've
been using credit and whether you've made payments on time
determine your credit worthiness.
The
lender wants to know, ‘If I lend money to 100 or 1,000 or 10,000
borrowers with these characteristics, will 90% or 95% or 99%
repay?’
For years, the entire credit scoring process was shrouded in
mystery. Fair Isaac and other scoring firms said that if they
revealed the scoring system -- and the exact criteria to
determine that score -- their services wouldn’t be needed
anymore.
In
June 2000, Fair, Isaac surrendered to increasing pressure from
Congress and consumer groups and released a list of the criteria
it uses to determine credit scores. In addition, the company
plans to develop a web feature so you can check your own score.
The
five main criteria are:
-
Your payment
history payment history on credit cards, retail accounts at
stores, installment loans, and mortgages. 35% of total score
-
Amounts
owed. What is important is how many accounts have balances
and how much of the total credit line is being used on
credit cards and other "revolving credit" accounts. 30% of
total score.
-
Length of
credit history. That’s why parents should help children
establish credit histories before they go out on their own.
15% of total score.
-
New credit.
Applying for too much new credit is one of the easiest ways
for people to inadvertently harm their credit score. (10% of
total score)
-
Types of
credit. This takes into account your mix of installment
loans, mortgages, retail accounts, credit cards and finance
company accounts. (10% of total score)
The scores that companies like Fair, Isaac compile are sent to
the credit reporting agencies as composite numbers. In addition
to your salary and other factors mentioned above, here are some
of the things that scoring agencies consider:
-
Your
education level. It sounds arbitrary, but it’s true. A
college-educated person is given more “points” than a high
school graduate, for example.
-
The number
of years you’ve lived in a single location. If you’ve moved
around a lot, you lose precious points. If you’ve moved
because of a better-paying job, you can recoup some of those
points if your salary has increased, for example.
-
The number
of years you’ve worked for a single employer. Scoring
agencies like people who are stable. That’s why they assign
more points to people who’ve lived in a particular place for
several years or who’ve worked for a single employer for
many years.
-
Are you a
homeowner? If you are, you get additional points. Renters
are considered more transient and less reliable to repay
their loans.
If all of this sounds arbitrary or unfair, remember that
scoring systems have allowed department stores and other lending
agencies to offer those “on-the-spot” credit approvals. You know
the routine. You fill out some basic information on a card and
five minutes later (if the computer is working properly), you’re
either approved or disapproved for a loan.
Credit scoring spurs growth
Credit
scoring has helped fuel the economic boom of the 1990s because
it allowed those who grant credit to grant much more of it --
20% to 30% more, by some estimates -- than they otherwise would
have.
Credit
at lower rates is available to a broader spectrum of American
consumers than anyone could have imagined just a generation
ago,.
There are a lot of elements stored in the computer.
Even
a fairly simple credit scoring system is likely to have 10,000
or 20,000 different possible combinations. That's a lot of
information to keep straight. What if it gets scrambled up?
OK,
YOU know it isn't realistic to think that Jimmy Stewart is going
to loan any of us the money to buy a home today. But he's
worried about your financial viability -- your ability to borrow
money, get a job, buy a home or rent an apartment. It all
depends on a database that’s supposed to be fail-safe. Howard's
favorite movie is "Dr. Strangelove," the Cold War satire in
which a mad U.S. general finds a loophole that allows him to
launch a nuclear strike against the Soviet Union. So back in the
real world, could this one credit database have a flaw that
could destroy your hopes of buying a new home?
You’re about to know more
Some
things would seem obvious in credit scoring. A high income earns
more points than a low income
Fair, Isaac is only part of the process. Once the company
processes a score, it is then transmitted to the lender, which
makes the ultimate decision on whether a credit application is
approved or denied. Lenders insist that the scoring system does
not unfairly hurt minorities, but simply reflects overall
lending histories.
How to improve your score
But,
of course, we will try to improve our credit scores, won't we?
There are certain things we do know. Fewer credit cards are
better than several cards. Paying on time is a must.
Some
of the things that weigh heavily are stability -- both at home
and on the job -- and a good payment history.
|
CREDIT GRADES |
|
Rating |
Debt to
Income Ratio |
Mortgage
Lates |
Consumer
Lates |
Collections,
Chargeoffs & Judgments |
Bankruptcy &
Foreclosure |
|
A+ |
45%-55% |
No more than
1x30 in the last 12 months |
limited 30
day lates |
Last 24 mos -
All must be satisfied |
none w/in
last 3 yrs |
|
A- |
50% |
No more than
2x30 in the last 12 months |
30 days lates,
limited 60 day lates |
Last 24 mos-can
remain open- Max of $1000 |
none w/in
last 2/3yrs depending on LTV |
|
B |
50% |
No more than
3x30 in the last 12 months |
Last 12 mo
-limited 60 day lates |
Last 24 mo -
max of $2500-Can remain open |
18 months out
of bankruptcy or foreclosure |
|
B- |
50% |
No more than
4x30 or 1x60 in the last 12 months |
limited 90s
and 120s in last 12 months |
Last 24 mo -
Max of $2500-can remain open |
18 months out
of bankruptcy or foreclosure |
|
C |
50% |
5x30; 2x60 or
1x90 in last 12 months |
Last 12
months 120s |
Last 24 mo-
Max of $5000 - can remain open |
12 months out
of bankruptcy or foreclosure |
|
D |
50% |
4 mos
delinquent at closing |
Significant
current and past problems |
Last 24
mo-Max of $5000- can remain open |
Prior to
closing Ch7 min - 12 Mos |
|
The
figures shown here are estimates. When trying to figure your
credit grade, keep in mind the following principles:
Other
Things Being Equal
When your have bad credit, all of the other aspects of the loan
need to be in order. Equity, stability, income, documentation
and assets play a larger role in the approval decision.
Worst Case
Scenario
When determining your grade, various combinations are allowed,
but the worst case will push your grade to a lower credit guide.
Late mortgage payments and
bankruptcies and foreclosures are the most
important.
Going Once,
Going Twice
Credit patterns are very important. A high number of recent
inquiries and more than a few outstanding loans may signal a
problem. A "willingness to pay" is important, thus late payments
in the same time period is better than random late payments as
they signal an effort to pay even after falling behind.
The
scoring system looks at how close you are to the limits on your
cards, what you spend money on and how much you ask for in cash
advances. If you are above 50% of your limit, this may adversely
affect your score. It is better to have two cards, each with say
49% of the limit, instead of having one card with 98% of the
limit. If your balances are high or close to your limit, you can
call your credit card company and ask them to increase your
credit limit. It is better to have a balance of $2,800 on a
$10,000 credit limit than to have it on a $5,000 limit. Bankers
are funny that way. Pay attention. But don't despair.
For people with damaged credit …
If you don’t
have a credit card, you should open an account, charge
something,
and pay
promptly. You must have open trade lines (credit accounts) with
a good
payment
history to get a favorable score. If you are having trouble
getting approved,
open a secured
credit card. This is where you make a deposit in the bank and
they
issue you a
credit card up to the amount of the deposit. If you pay your
bills on
time, they
will probably increase your credit limit to one and one half or
two times
your deposit.
This is especially helpful to people who have had a recent
bankruptcy.
The
best-secured credit card program I have found is Old Orchard
Bank,
WWW.ORCHARDBANK.COM. You can also find them at
WWW.EXPERTCREDIT.COM.
Check them out if you need them.
Department stores tend to have more liberal credit policies
than banks. They want you to spend money in their store. Hence,
they are eager to issue new credit cards. Stores such as
Filenes, Lowes, JC Penny, and Sears all have credit cards. Oil
cards from Mobile, Getty, and Shell are also a good place to
start or rebuild your credit.
You can also
take out a secured personal loan. This is where you make a
deposit at a bank and take out a personal loan using the deposit
as security. This may sound foolish, but remember that you are
trying to build up your credit score, not actually borrow the
money. An increased credit score could save you many thousands
of dollars in interest payments when you decide to purchase a
home.
Car dealers
must sell cars. They must move that car off the lot and will
provide liberal financing to people to do so. If you need a new
or used car, consider financing the vehicle. Pay off the loan in
a few months and have points added to your credit score.
Another
excellent method of improving your credit score is to get
someone to allow you to become an authorized user on their
account. Ask a relative or close friend. Thusly, you inherit
their good payment history. If you want, become an authorized
user, receive a credit card on someone else account, and then
cut
up the
card. This will add many points to your credit score. (Cutting
up the card won’t, but being on the account that is in good
standing will).
A word on
credit councilors and debt adjusters. Some of these agencies
will offer to negotiate down your balances and put you on a
payment program. Be careful!. Entering into such an arrangement
will most likely lower your credit score a lot.
If you have
derogatory information on your credit report, consider disputing
it. Write a letter of dispute to the credit agency explaining
why you do not owe the money or were late making a payment. If
you do not owe the money for whatever reason, you should dispute
it.
If you owe
money to a creditor and have been late with your payments, and
are in a position to make payments or pay off the entire debt,
contact the creditor and try to cut a deal. In exchange for
regular payments. Ask them to report your account to the credit
agency as paid on time or paid in full. Creditors want to get
paid. They do not want to ruin someone’s credit or get sued.You
can ask them for a release, in writing, of the late payment
history and then report it to the credit bureau.
In the case
of utility bills, you may be able to have a portion of the bill
forgiven. Check out the available programs. A letter with a big
sob story and an offer to make payments may persuade the utility
company to report your account as paying on time.
Wireless
companies that have you sign a contract may forgive any
penalties if you sign back on with them, paying for any time
used. You can ask them to release you from any lates and get
such lates taken off your credit report. Maybe there was a
misunderstanding with the service. An angry customer is bad for
business.
Late
payments may be taken off with a letter to customer service.
Sometimes a payment will take two weeks to get there. This is
clearly not your fault. If this is the case, dispute it to
customer service and to the credit agency. I was having a
problem with my mortgage payments getting to the lender on time
even though I had been mailing them two weeks ahead of their due
date. I reverted to overnight express mail but did not like the
cost and the hassle of having to go to the post office to send
the payment. I switched to auto pay so the mortgage payment is
now deducted from my checking account. End of problem.
In the case
of medical bills, it is a fact that hospitals, doctors, medical
facilities charge self paying patients up to four or five times
what they charge social security and private insurance companies
for medical procedures. Their excuse for this is that they offer
a discount for volume business or for a virtual guarantee that
they will get paid. I personally don’t accept this. If you feel
that you are being cheated or gouged, you should dispute the
bill, item by item. Always get an itemized medical or hospital
bill. You may be able to negotiate the bill down to a reasonable
level, even without going to court or hiring an attorney. If you
do end up settling, even if you have been late with your
payments, you can write a letter asking the doctor or medical
facility to report you as paid on time. Some of them will have
mercy on you and help you out.
You can
have derogatory information removed from your credit report by
using the services of an agency that specializes in that sort of
thing. The money they charge may be worth it if it helps you get
a lower rate on a mortgage. Ask your loan officer for
references.
You should
get a copy of your credit report and review it carefully. Check
for inaccuracies. If you have incurred a business debt and the
debt is more than six years old, you may be off the hook, due to
the statue of limitations. If you have a judgment against you,
they are usually good for 17 years. Check with an attorney. If
you have gone bankrupt, all debts included in your bankruptcy
should read as discharged in the bankruptcy on your credit
report. Creditors do not always report them as having been
discharged. You may have to do some work. Student loans are not
dischargeable through bankruptcy in the State of Connecticut.
They are, however, dischargeable in the State of Florida.
Certain stipulations apply.
If someone
is reporting clearly erroneous derogatory information about you,
you can file a complaint against them through the Connecticut
Department of Consumer Affairs, the Connecticut Banking
Commission, and the Connecticut Attorney General’s Office. I’d
also throw in the Better Business Bureau and the local Chamber
of Commerce, and also a few newspapers. But remember, you must
be able to prove that you are right and have made an effort to
resolve the dispute.
Finally, it
is possible to sue away the derogatory information on your
credit report if it is incorrect. If someone says that you owe
them money and you don’t and they do not have a valid claim
against you, you can sue them. You simply sue the organization
reporting the derogatory information and the credit agency. You
must provide proof and prove your case. Before doing this, you
should at least consult with an attorney. I would ask the judge
to order the derogatory information be removed from the credit
report and for the judge to award punitive damages for
defamation of credit and an unfair trade practice. You can sue
in small claims (Connecticut) where the limit in damages is
$3,500 in Connecticut or in Superior Court where damages are
virtually unlimited. You will probably need a lawyer to sue
someone in Superior court, so it is not something to rush into.
You should also consider that the other party will probably
press their claim in court. You will probably be sued for the
money they say that you owe. They, of course will have to prove
that you owe the money. If they win, you now have a judgment
against you which is more that just someone saying that you owe
money. If you win and they loose, they are prohibited upon
penalties from the court, from saying that you owe them
anything. If the judge says that you owe nothing, guess what?
You owe nothing.
If you are
concerned about your credit report, the first step is to obtain
a copy from each of the three major agencies:
EQUIFAX
http://www.equifax.com
PO
Box 105873
Atlanta, GA 30348
800-685-1111
Experion
http://www.experian.com
PO
Box 2002
Allen, TX 75013
Consumer Credit Questions
888-EXPERIAN (888-397-3742)
Trans
Union
www.transunion.com
Post Office Box 2000
Chester, PA 19022
(800) 916-8800
(800) 851-2674
This is
often referred to as a tri-merged FICO credit report. You can
contact the agencies directly, or use a service like
WWW.MYFICO.COM. They offer some interesting products,
but also charge a fee. There is also a service through
WWW.IDENTITYGUARD.COM, where you can get three credit
reports, including scores, for three months for $24.95. Pulling
your own report will not affect your credit score.
Improving
your score does take time – two weeks, six months, two years,
depending on the circumstances. The most common timeframe after
the information on the credit report has been corrected or
changed is 45 to 60 days. If someone offers to improve your
score overnight and especially for a large fee, forget about it.
Contact your loan officer to get some reliable advice.